Question

The manager, _____ it clear to us that he didn't agree with us, left the meeting room.

The manager, _____ it clear to us that he didn't agree with us, left the meeting room.
A who has made B having made C made D making
这里好象ABCD都可以啊, 为什么选B呢

Answer 1

选B
相当于非限制性定语从句。用who had made 也是正确的。但是选项中没有。
A 改为who had made。是“过去”left的过去，所以用过去完成式。
c 的话，改为The manager made it clear to us that he didn't agree with us and left the meeting room.
d。。。。

Answer 2

应该用who had made，因为ing分词的完成体不能做定语，只可做状语。如果The manager 后有逗号，则可用having made做状语

Answer 3

从句中两个动作发生的顺序可知，应用完成时态，即“经理先清楚地向我们表明他不同意我们的意见，然后离开了会议室”。答案 B.

动词的doing形式在具体语境中的运用以及与定语从句之间的转换，having made可用who had made代替。

Answer 4

记得了