Question

1.Where do you think he bought the computer? 此句为什么不能用完成时表达:

where do you think he has bought the compute?
2.look, i have bought a new computer ,---cool, (where did you but it? )请问括号内的能用现在完成时表达吗?
3.where have you been during the winter holiday ,Millie? where did you go during your stay in Hong Kong? 请问这两个句子意思差不多,为什么时态不一样? 是因为表达的意思不一样吗?

Answer 1

楼主的提问写得比较模糊啊。。。。。。

1、Where do you think he bought the computer? 意为你认为他的电脑在哪儿买的？
这句不能用现在完成时来表达。
现在完成时表述的是过去某一时间开始并一直持续到现在并且有可能还会持续的动作或状态。而他买电脑显然是过去已经发生的动作，并未持续到现在，显然应该使用过去式。
2、where did you but it?
你可以用完成时来表达。
例如where have you bought it?
但不能说where have you bought it last year?当有明确的过去时间做状语的时候只能用过去式。
3.where have you been during the winter holiday ,Millie? where did you go during your stay in Hong Kong?

实际上你可以换过来用，比如where did you go during the winter holiday ,Millie?或者where have you been during your stay in Hong Kong?

Answer 2

1. 你在提问的时候他买电脑的动作已经不在延续,不对现在造成任何结果了..你只是问他在哪里吗?其实你就是在问WHERE DID HE BUY THE COMPUTER?

2. 和第一句的解释一样。。。

3. where have you been during the winter holiday？问的人知道millie去了一些地方，但是不知道他去过什么地方，where did you go？问的人根本不知道你在香港期间是否有外出。翻译为：MILLIE，你寒假期间去了哪些地方？   你在香港期间都去哪儿？