Question

如何写好 Response to reviewer

Answer 1

最重要的一点是，不要跟reviewer吵架。要先顺着reviewer说，具体如下：
reviewer说你这个地方说不通啊
回答：I agree with you about + reviewer的观点， but from another perspective, 我这个说法也对
reviewer说你缺实验啊
回答：Thank you for your suggestion about + reviewer说的实验，It will be included in our future work. But in this paper we mainly discussed + 你自己的文章的主题
reviewer 说你这里这里要改
回答： Thank you for your suggestions, the part has been modified accordingly and highlighted in the revised submission.
基本就这么三类，照着来基本没有问题。其实当编辑给你修改机会的时候就是想发表你的文章了。祝你文章早日发表，早日毕业——

Answer 2

最重要的一点是，不要跟reviewer吵架。要先顺着reviewer说，具体如下：
reviewer说你这个地方说不通啊
回答：I agree with you about + reviewer的观点, but from another perspective, 我这个说法也对
reviewer说你缺实验啊
回答：Thank you for your suggestion about + reviewer说的实验，It will be included in our future work. But in this paper we mainly discussed + 你自己的文章的主题
reviewer 说你这里这里要改
回答： Thank you for your suggestions, the part has been modified accordingly and highlighted in the revised submission.
基本就这么三类，照着来基本没有问题。其实当编辑给你修改机会的时候就是想发表你的文章了。祝你文章早日发表，早日毕业~