Question

定语从句的一个问题

1. The girl _____ I think was honest lied to me.
2. The girl ______ I think to be honest lied to me.
第一句答案who'，第二句答案是whom
我认为这句话是不是把i think 看做是插入语？
想问的是，第二句话，先行词the girl在定语从句中做宾语？？那主语是什么？整句话怎么分析，第一句、第二句有怎么理解句式呢？

Answer 1

1. The girl _____ I think was honest lied to me.

I think 是插入语。句子还可以作如下调整：
在句尾插入：The girl who was honest lied to me, I think .
改为宾语从句：I think the girl who was honest lied to me.
无论如何改动，who was honest 都是定语从句，who 是关系代词，指代 the girl，在从句中作主语 。

2. The girl ______ I think to be honest lied to me.

本句中用了 think sb. to be (认为某人如何) 的句型，即 think the girl to be honest, 因此句子的结构为：
主句：The girl lied to me.
定语从句：whom I think to be honest （关系代词在从句中作 think 的宾语）。

Answer 2

问：我认为这句话是不是把i think 看做是插入语？

答：第一句1. The girl _____ I think was honest lied to me.
可以把I think 看做是插入语，也可以直接看做主语。
如果看做插入语，直接可以拿掉不看，既是the girl was honest. the girl 作主语。用who
如果不看做插入语，既是 i think that the girl was honest. the girl做宾语从句的主语，同样用who

问：第二句话，先行词the girl在定语从句中做宾语？？那主语是什么？整句话怎么分析？

答：第二句2. The girl ______ I think to be honest lied to me.
这句话i think 不应看做是插入语哦，就是定语从句。
补充完整该句子应该是i think the girl to be honest。to be honest 这儿是动词不定时做宾语补足语哦，与i want him to be tall.或者 I want him to help me。是一样的道理。
以此“the girl”做“宾语”因此用whom，主语是“I”。

O(∩_∩)O~

Answer 3

1. The girl _____ I think was honest lied to me.
2. The girl ______ I think to be honest lied to me.
第一句答案who'，第二句答案是whom
我认为这句话是不是把i think 看做是插入语？
想问的是，第二句话，先行词the girl在定语从句中做宾语？？那主语是什么？整句话怎么分析，第一句、第二句有怎么理解句式呢？

1. The girl __who___ I think was honest lied to me.

看原句:
the girl lied to me

I think (that) the girl was honest.
因为定语从句,有 that了,所以定语从句用who ,that尽量别用.

就成了:The girl (who) I think was honest lied to me.

2. The girl ___whom___ I think to be honest lied to me.

the girl lied to me

I think her (to be honest ).
括号内是补语.

her是宾格,是think 的宾语,所以严格来说.

The girl ___whom___ I think to be honest lied to me.
也要用宾格.

Answer 4

The girl who I think was honest lied to me. i think 看做是插入语
The girl whom I think to be honest lied to me. girl在句子做主语，同时是定语从句think这动作的宾语，可拆分为："I think the girl to be honest, but she lied to me.”
我觉得你分析语法的能力不错，我说得较笼统，相信你也会明白的。

Answer 5

1. The girl (_who_ I think was honest ) lied to me.
the girl 做主语，用who
2. The girl (_whom_ I think to be honest ) lied to me.
to be 至关重要，说明是不定式的被动语态，所以the girl 在括号内的从句中变为了宾语，在主句中仍然是主语。