Question

I told Sally how to get there , but her perhaps I

I told Sally how to get there , but her perhaps I ____for her. A. had to write it out B. must have written it out C. should have written it out D. ought to write it out 为什么选A,不选BCD

Answer 1

选A的意思是 我告诉了sally怎么到那里,但是她也许不得不把它写下来. (因为她太可能记得住怎么走)

I told Sally how to get there , but I perhaps ____for her 如果题目把Her 换成 i , 应该选 C. 意思为 我告诉了sally怎么到那里,但是我应该把它写下来给她. (因为sally不太可能一次就记得住)

Answer 2

I told Sally how to get there , but her perhaps I ____for her.
对这道题有两点疑问，一是 but her perhaps I 这里可能有错；二是 就目前看到的这个题干，选C更合适： 我给Sally讲过怎么走，不过也许我（不该只是嘴上讲一讲就完，而是）应该给她写下来。

Answer 3

为什么我觉得这里有成分缺失？perhaps后面怎么突然变成I了？前面意思应该是我和Sally说了怎么过去，不过可能她记不住，接下去应该得表现出不得不的意思来所以说had to(过去式)

追问

为什么不选C

没有缺失阿

追答

but后面怎么会有个her？这样就有两个主语了啊，如果没有her对应的句子少了那就是多了这个her……should表示应该，必须的意思，语境不符。因为这里有个but，那就必须表达一种有转折的意思。意思就是我都说过了，但是还是得写出来好，那这句话里就有一种被迫的意味，所以就是have to