Question

Mr Green must have been punished for his being rude at the meeting,didn‘t he

这句话对吗？

Answer 1

不对！
didn't ---wasn't
情态动词表推测时，该句的反义疑问句和情态动词无关，必须去掉该情态动词后，考虑句子谓语动词的发生时间和谓语构成，再进行相应的变化。
如:
It must have rained last night, didn't it?
去掉must后，考虑时间状语last night，说明句子本该使用一般过去时，即变成:It rained last night，所以其反义疑问句为didn't it?

你的句子相当于
Mr Green was punished for his being rude at the meeting , wasn't he?

Answer 2

“must+have+done”表示对过去事情的肯定推测，译成“一定做过某事”，该结构只用于肯定句。

Answer 3

改成 Haven't he?就不算错，简单说:这个问句是虚问的教训式口语，只要改成Haven't力道还在;

Answer 4

wasn‘t he

Answer 5

引用heilaoda88818的回答：
不对！
didn't ---wasn't
情态动词表推测时，该句的反义疑问句和情态动词无关，必须去掉该情态动词后，考虑句子谓语动词的发生时间和谓语构成，再进行相应的变化。
如:
It must have rained last night, didn't it?
去掉must后，考虑时间状语last night，说明句子本该使用一般过去时，即变成:It rained last night，所以其反义疑问句为didn't it?

你的句子相当于
Mr Green was punished for his being rude at the meeting , wasn't he?

这个是对的，反义疑问句用法