Question

一道sat语法题

17. in additional to being a talented pianist and composer, B was a respected musicologist who wrote several books on Hungarian, Slovakian, and Romanian folk music. E
答案为E，我选择了B，因为我认为此处的being是不必要的，这里没有必要刻意的表示一个状态。直接in additional to a talented。。。， B was a。。 不是并列的更好吗？

Answer 1

在SAT语法中 首先 in additional to doing 这个用法没有错 being就没有错 这里考的是搭配 在ISE中 being having 划线不算错 因为这里是 identify sentence error 是句子挑错 不是IS improving sentence 改善句子 一般看到固定搭配没错的题再ISE中 就选E..注意 不是什么更好不更好 是选哪个错了! IS中是选更好的选项 但是ISE中是挑错..不要搞混

Answer 2

首先，我认为in additional to是错的，应该是in addition to 。其次，后半句B was。。。中谓语动词是was ，前半句中的谓语动词因为在介词之后，所以前后谓语动词的形式并不一致，故前前半句的谓语动词是不可省略的，它并不是用来可以的表示一个状态。可以详细参考省略语法。

Answer 3

In addition to being a talented pianist and composer, Bela Bartok was a respected musicologist who wrote several books on Hungarian, Slovakian, and Romanian folk music.
In addition to( being) a talented pianist and composer=Apart from the fact that he (was) a talented pianist and composer 他除了(是)一位有才能的钢琴家和作曲家以外...

这句话中，being a talented pianist and composer 是 动名词短语，作介词 to 的宾语，being 可要可不要，但并不算错误。

Answer 4

不加BEING就不通顺，这是固定的句式