Question

问一个英语问题。请问下图第16题为什么不选d？

Answer 1

Many people who had seen the film were afraid to go to the forest when they remembered the scenes ________ people were eaten by the tiger．
[　A　]
A．
in which
B．
by which
C．
which
D．
that
答案：A

解析：

由四个选项知空格处应填入定语从句的引导词，
其句意为“people were eaten by the tiger in the scene”，
所以先行词scenes应与介词in搭配。

追问

请问填that有问题吗？

Answer 2

我觉得选A，填in which。
Many people who had seen the film were afraid to go to the forest when they remembered the scenes _____ people were eaten by the tiger。
who had seen the film是修饰先行词people的定语从句，把主句提出来是：Many people were afraid to go to the forest。后面的when they remembered the scenes是时间状语，再后面的部分是做forest的定语从句，划线部分在从句中做地点状语，没有where，所以用的in which。（可以用in the forest帮助理解。）

追问

请问如用that会有什么问题？最后的从句一定是修饰forest吗？不能是修饰scenes？

追答

如果是修饰scenes，那scenes在从句中做什么成分呢？我们判断关系词用什么一般是通过先行词在从句中做什么成分判断的。

Answer 3

定语从句主语宾语齐全，不能用关系代词，这是考虑构成状语，用介词+关系代词，根据scene，所以用a。

Answer 4

A
把定语从句分开就是people were eaten by the tiger in the scene.
故选A
that在定语从句中作主语或宾语，不作状语。

追问

请问选that的问题在哪？

Answer 5

这道题d也是对的，in which=where=that