Question

两道非谓语选择题.求解释

1.Do you consider it any good ______again?
A to try B.try C.trying. D for you to try
2.Do you think it any good ___with him again?
据说选to talk.
第一题 选C。 D为什么不可以

请问 这两句不都是it 作形式宾语吗？不是I consider/ think it is good to....... 这样吗？
请帮忙加以区分谢谢！

Answer 1

1.Do you consider it any good ______again?
A to try B.try C.trying. D for you to try
2.Do you think it any good ___with him again?
据说选to talk.
第一题 选C。 D为什么不可以
请问 这两句不都是it 作形式宾语吗？不是I consider/ think it is good to....... 这样吗？
请帮忙加以区分谢谢！
答：这个问题问得好！
第一题选C
译：你认为再试有用处吗？
析：本题考查形式宾语和真正宾语。源于形式主语it和真正主语it
我们知道，不定式和动名词都可以作主语。如用形式主语it,真正的主语多为不定式：
句型1：it is +adj. + to do sth. 如：it is important to do sth.
句型2：it is +n. +to do sth. 如：it is good manners to do sth.
只有下面这种情况下才用动名词作真正的主语：
It is no good/ no use doing sth.
可能因为成语：it is no good crying over the spilt milk. 之故。
所以第一题源于：Do you consider that it is any good trying again?
-->Do you consider it any good trying again?
“consider 后面只能跟 动名词作宾语 所以其他选项错”，这样的回答是有问题的。这里的真正宾语用动名词，不是因为consider是一个只能跟动名词作宾语（不能跟不定式作宾语）的单宾动词。 consider doing sth. 中的consider作“考虑”解释。当consider 作“认为”解释时，是复宾动词，后跟形容词、名词作宾语补足语。
如：We consider him (to be/as) honest (/an honest man) 我们认为他是一个诚实的人。
没有规定其宾语一定要用动名词，根据需要，可以是名词，可以是不定式，也可以是动名词。
这里真宾用动名词是因为句型：it is no good doing sth. 如将any good 改成necessary,则应用不定式作真宾。
请看网上的例句：
We consider it necessary to protect animals.
Before entering this site, we consider it necessary to briefly introduce you to our website.
I consider it necessary to brush three times a day.
第二题中的think与consider可以互换，都是“认为”，都是跟复合宾语，宾补都是any good,由
I think (that) it is no good doing sth. 变化而来。所以你的那个据说的答案“to talk”并不符合考试英语，也不符合语言习惯。因为有It is no good/ no use criying over spilt milk. 这个widespread的谚语。
关于第二题的答案，我认为是在多人改编题目的过程中走样了的结果。
可能原题句是：
Do you think it good ___with him again?
A to talk B talking C to talking D having talked
答案是A 没错，因为这里的good是形容词，it is good to do sth. 与it is no good doing sth.不是一个句型，good的词性也不一样，后者中的good 是名词，与do good to sb. / do sb. good中的good词性相同，是抽象不可数名词，意为“好处”，可以被限定词no, any修饰。

有人将这一题根据“语感”，在good前加了一个any, 从而改变了句型。但答案没有改。

附：从一道高考题看 consider 的用法
动词consider既可作“考虑”讲, 又可作“看作”讲, 二者有什么区别呢? 让我们走近consider, 看看它有哪些用法吧。
93 NMET试题中的一道单项选择题是:
Charles Babbage is generally considered ______ the first computer.
A. to invent
B. inventing
C. to have invented
D. having invented
此题考查的就是consider的用法。让我们对consider的用法作一归纳, 然后, 再做答案。
一、consider意为“考虑, 细想”时, 其后可跟:
1. 名词或代词:
We must consider the matter from different standpoints.
我们应当从各个角度来考虑一下这件事。
We must consider it very carefully. 我们应仔细地考虑它。
2. 从句:
We must consider what's to be done. 我们必须考虑该怎么办。
He considered how he should answer. 他考虑应当怎样回答。
3. “疑问词＋不定式”:
Have you considered how to get there? 你是否考虑过如何到那里?
We have to consider what material to use first. 我们先得考虑用什么材料。
注意: consider作“考虑”解时, 不能直接接不定式。
4. 动名词:
He considered going to see them in person. 他考虑亲自去看望他们。
He is considering changing his job. 他在考虑调换一下工作。
5. 介词over或单独用:
He said they had considered over it. 他说他们已经考虑过了。
Let me consider. 让我考虑一下。
二、consider意为“认为, 以为, 把……看作”, 其后可跟:
1. 从句:
We consider that a friend in need is a friend indeed.
我们认为患难之友才是真正的朋友。
2. 名词的复合结构（即名词作宾语补足语）:
We consider Beijing the heart of our country.
我们认为北京是我国的心脏。
3. 带形容词的复合结构:
They considered me too young to do the work.
他们认为我太年轻, 干不了这项工作。
4. 带不定式的复合结构:
We consider only such methods to be correct.
我们认为只有这样的方法才是正确的。
注意: 不定式后主要是be, 间或为其它动词（多为完成式）。
We all considered him to have stolen Tom's wallet.
我们都以为是他偷了汤姆的钱包。
5. 带介词短语的复合结构:
We always consider these people as our true comrades.
我们一向认为这些人是我们真正的同志。
They always consider themselves in the right. 他们总认为自己对。
6. 带“it形式宾语＋形容词＋真正宾语（动词不定式、从句等）”:
We consider it our duty to help her. 我们认为帮助她是我们的职责。
I consider it a great pleasure that I can work with you.
我觉得能和你在一起工作是极大的快乐。
注意: consider作“认为”解时, 一般不接动名词。
综上所述, 我们可以看出前文所提的93年的那道高考题考查的是consider作“认为”解时的用法, 题干是被动式, 改为主动式为:
We generally consider Charles Babbage ______ the first computer. 不难看出, 这一句子的基本结构为: 主语＋谓语＋复合宾语（名词＋动词不定式）, 答案应选动词不定式。因“发明”这一动作已经发生, 故应选to have invented, 即C。
练习: I. 选择填空。
1. They have been considering ______ the problem.
a. to work out
b. work out
c. working out
d. worked out
2. I consider Tom ______ the finest basketball player today.
a. to be
b. being
c. was
d. be
3. I don't know ______ .
a. whether they will consider visiting the Summer Palace
b. whether will they consider to visit the Summer Palace
c. whether they will consider to visit the Summer Palace
d. whether they will consider visit the Summer Palace
4. Our monitor ______ to be an honest man.
a. considers
b. is considering
c. was considered
d. has considered
II. 根据第一句完成第二句, 每空填一词, 使句意不变。
1. He was considering repairing the watch.
He was considering ______ ______ ______ the watch.
2. We consider Lu Xun one of the greatest writers in China.
Lu Xun ______ ______ one of the greatest writers in China.
3. We considered that it was necessary to do so.
We considered ______ ______ to do so.
4. I consider the report to be wrong.
I consider the report ______ .
Key: I. 1. c 2. a 3. a 4. c
II. 1. how to repair 2. is considered 3. it necessary 4. wrong

Answer 2

第一题答案是C 这是 it是 修饰宾语 动名词短语作真宾语 any good 这里是名词 作宾补
consider 后面只能跟 动名词作宾语 所以其他选项 错
第二题 答案 to talk
这也是it作形式宾语 any good 做宾补 不定式短的动作语作 作真宾语 根据不定式的特征 这是表示将要发生
道理很简单 因为consider 后面不能跟不定式 作宾语 这是规定
而think 后面可以跟 含有不定式的复合 宾语 这也是规定

Answer 3

费解

Answer 4

consider doing sth这个你知道嘛！我们可以把宾语trying后置到补语good之后，前面就需要以形式宾语it了噻。
例如： I think it difficult for me to achieve this dream. 到底后面用动名词还是不定式取决于前面动词，事情的事态（已发生或未发生）或语言环境。

Answer 5

consider doing sothing