Question

Counter offer

Answer 1

更新1:

希望law高手请帮下手^^

, 更新2:

(3)如果有个人make offer$6800去卖电话俾buyer,buyer回应系"aept offer,是否系nokia"算唔算系aept offer

,If Man agreed to make the offer opened for 3 days waiting for Lin to aept within 3 days, then, there is an obligation being made beeen Man and Lin. If Lin aept the offer within 3 days, then there is an aeptance to Man's offer and thus a valid contract being made. If Lin does not give Man his intention after 3 days, then the offer made by Man is then lapsed, There is no contract being made beeen Man and Lin and Man could sell the phone to anybody aepting his offer.

In this issue, Man does not give an offer opened to Lin for 2 days and Lin does not aepted the offer immediately, there is no contract being made binding each party. Man could therefore sell the phone to David.

No. The buyer is still demanding the seller for further details of the phone. There is no offer and aeptance as further details is still required. Hence, no contract at all.

2009-11-04 09:41:03 补充：
1. If both parties agreed that the offer will expired after 3 days and, if Man sell the phone before asking Lin for any aeptance, then Man is in breach.

2009-11-04 09:41:10 补充：
2. It all depends on the terms of the offer and aeptance. If Man demands immediate aeptance, then the offer will lapsed if Lin does not aept but make an counter offer of 3 days. Man could sell the phone to any other person as counter offer me no contract at all.,这里可以帮到你
yayan.ok114/yahooauction/1118037410,如果以第一个case黎讲,如果lin话俾3日决定买/唔买,而啊man3日内卖左电话冇通知lin,而lin三日内决定aept左既话,系咪man就会毁约??

第2个case,man make offer,,系咪lin立刻要aept,咁man几时可以卖给其他人??,